Fitbit Surge vs Jawbone UP3

Fitbit Surge

JAWBONE UP3

Fitbit Surge is no ordinary fitness wristband but is an intelligent Fitness Superwatch for active people. Just in the era of ubiquitous, cheap smart watches, a simple wristband is not enough. In addition to the number of steps, distance and time spent actively we expect from these devices much more. Hence, we are given a new model Fitbit Surge. Thanks to the modifications and numerous sensors is the most promising model on the market, which also takes competition with smartwatches. This model is available for less than $250. Let's start with the specification. Read More
Jawbone UP3 is the newest line of bands from the company jawbone. Compared to the UP2 band has been enriched with several new sensors and functions of which the most useful is Heart Health Monitoring. However, these modifications affected the price UP3 that is about $180. Read More

1. Specifications

Fitbit Surge
VS
JAWBONE UP3
Wristband-Watch
Type
Wristband
Black
Blue
Tangerine
Colours
Silver
Black
Small 5.5” - 6.3” Large 6.3” - 7.8” Extra Large 7.8” - 8.9”
Wristband Size
wrist sizes ranging 140mm–190mm
wristband is made of flexible, durable elastomer material & surgical-grade stainless steel clasp
Materials
Medical-grade hypoallergenic TPU rubber Anodized aluminum with less than 0.5% nickel
Touch screen Monochrome LCD Backlight for low light visibility
Display
Three single color LEDs: Blue for sleep, orange for activity, and white for notifications
up to 7 days
Battery life:
7 days
Lithium-polymer
Battery type:
Lithium-Ion Polymer, 38 mAh Battery
1-2 hours
Charge time:
100 min.
-4° to 113°F
Operating temperature:
no data
30,000 feet
Maximum operating altitude:
no data
It is sweat, rain and splash proof. However, the device is not swim proof.
Water Resistance
Splash-proof, splash-resistant, so no need to worry about rain, sweat from a hard workout or getting wet in the shower. Just don't submerge it.
Price

Fitbit Surge

JAWBONE UP3

Attention is paid in this device to its large, clear, monochrome touch screen where we can, in addition to the typical fitness function, read the notifications of our smartphone. There are only three colors of the device. Applied rechargeable battery allows for seven days work, which is a very good result in this class. Unfortunately, despite the basic water resistance, the device cannot be used while swimming. Read Full Specs
The wristband is equipped with three single colored LEDs Blue for sleep, orange for activity, and white for notifications. UP3 is only available in two colors. Applied rechargeable battery allows for seven days work, which is a very good result for this class of devices. Unfortunately, despite the basic water resistance, the device cannot be used while swimming Tracking
In addition to the already mentioned UP3’s Heart Health Monitoring feature, typical sensors for counting steps, distance travelled, calories burned and track daily activity have been incorporated within it. This device allows setting your own goals and achievements and shows the status of their implementation. UP3 also measures the quality of your sleep. Read Full Specs

2. Features

2a. Tracking Features

Fitbit Surge
VS
JAWBONE UP3
yes
Activity & Inactivity
yes
yes
Calorie Intake
yes
yes
Calories Burned
yes
yes
Distance
yes
yes
Elevation/Stairs
no
yes
Steps
yes
yes
Goal Setting
yes
yes
Heart Rate
yes
yes
Sleep Quality
yes
yes
Sleep Time
yes
yes
GPS tracking

Fitbit Surge

JAWBONE UP3

In addition to the standard sensors of counting steps, distance travelled, calories burned, tracking daily activity Fitbit Surge is equipped with a sensor that analyses the HR function of the heart so that you will learn useful data on which you made the effort and endurance of your body. And thanks to the GPS location measurement travelled during training route will be very accurate. GPS and eight different sensors will give you not only the distance travelled but also elevation of the hill. Thanks to different settings and applications, Surge can record different types of sports by providing relevant data for analysis. The system of setting targets and achievements I will not mention because it is the basis for this type of equipment for active people Fitbit Surge allows you to analyze the quality of sleep. It also has a mild vibrating alarm that will wake you in a natural way.
In addition to the already mentioned UP3’s Heart Health Monitoring feature, typical sensors for counting steps, distance travelled, calories burned and track daily activity have been incorporated within it. This device allows setting your own goals and achievements and shows the status of their implementation. UP3 also measures the quality of your sleep.

2b. Other Features

Fitbit Surge
VS
JAWBONE UP3
yes
Clock
no
yes
Alarm
yes
yes
Barcode Scanner
yes
yes
Online Portal
yes
yes
Reminders
yes
yes
Music control
no
yes
Notifications
no
yes
Call notifications
no
no
Extra non standard
Bio-impedance: Respiration Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) Skin temperature Ambient Temperature

Fitbit Surge

JAWBONE UP3

As I mentioned Fitbit Surge will show a lot of training data but this is not the end of its features. Surge of course acts as a standard watch but a person with a quick motion with his hand can read the messages from a paired smartphone. For athletes who like to listen to music during training, a library was added to the ability to control music in our smartphone.
As I mentioned UP3 possesses new sensors for measuring bio-impedance, Respiration, Galvanic Skin Response (GSR), skin temperature and Ambient Temperature. Just like the other models of the company, UP3 also has a barcode scanner so that combined with an extensive database of food can quickly enter data that will help calculate calories consumed.

3. Synchronization & Compatibility

Fitbit Surge
VS
JAWBONE UP3
iPhone 4S and later
iPad 3 and later
iOS Compatibility
yes
yes
Android Compatibility
yes
yes
Windows Phone Compatibility
no
Mac OS X 10.6 and up
Mac OS X Compatibility
no
Windows Vista and later
Windows Compatibility
no
Endomondo
IFITT
Lose It!
MapMyFitness
My Fitness Pal
Spark People
Compatible Applications
UP by Jawbone™

Fitbit Surge

JAWBONE UP3

You can watch progress in your training on your computer or smartphone. As for the amount of compatible systems, Fitbit device beats the competition. Fitbit Surge is compatible with iOS, Windows Phone, Mac OS X, Windows, and Android. For the latter Fitbit system is equipped with a NFC chip for faster pairing with Android. Through numerous applications you can share your results with friends which will certainly further motivate you to continue the effort. Available trap allow you to keep a detailed record of your activity, of meals, quality of sleep and many others. Additionally, in collaboration with a compatible smart weight Fitbit Aria Wi-Fi Scale will have at your disposal a full picture of the state of your body and achieved designated purposes.
UP3 is compatible with many smartphones working on iOS or Android operating system. Available on these devices Jawbone Software allows a detailed record of your activity, meals, and quality of sleep. While with internet community, members can share their results with family friends, which certainly will further motivate you to continue the effort.

4. The Bottom Line

Fitbit Surge
VS
JAWBONE UP3
3.3 out of 5 stars (7467 Reviews)
Read Customer Reviews
Customer Reviews
2.6 out of 5 stars (5012 Reviews)
Read Customer Reviews
• HR Monitor
• Touch screen
• Good support for users on the part of Fitbit
• Compatible with multiple systems and devices
Pros
• Price
• Design
• Compatible with multiple systems and devices
• HR monitoring
• Works with lots of applications
• Inability to swim with the device
Cons
• Inability to swim with the device
• No display of information
• Short battery life
BUY NOW

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *